Is it cruel and unusual to jail an unhoused person for camping on public property? Not according to the Supreme Court’s decision in Grants Pass v. Johnson last summer. The ruling overturned the 2018 9th U.S. Circuit’s Martin v. Boise precedent, which had prohibited punishing individuals for sleeping outdoors when shelters were unavailable.
However, Martin v. Boise was not absolute. It still allowed governments to enact time, place, and manner restrictions on camping on public land. Cities like Los Angeles were already exploiting this loophole by amending local laws like LA Municipal Code 41.18 to ban camping in vast swaths of the city. Los Angeles even perversely used the Americans with Disabilities Act to exclude unhoused people — but not outdoor dining areas — from sidewalks.
The Supreme Court decision now legitimizes similar strategies nationwide, enabling unlimited harassment and displacement of people trying to survive outside. Deeper issues remain: the commodification of housing, prioritizing profits over human needs, and creating the conditions for criminalization.
From commodification, criminalization
The roots of homelessness lie in treating homes as profit-making assets rather than survival necessities — a crisis starkly evident in Los Angeles County. Skyrocketing rents, stagnant wages, and luxury development policies have displaced nearly 80,000 Angelenos, while tax incentives and subsidies for developers only increase profits. Marginalized groups — especially people of color, LGBTQ+ individuals, and people with disabilities — bear the brunt, facing systemic discrimination and a lack of affordable housing.
Living on the streets means constant displacement and harassment. Unhoused individuals face brutal sweeps, where their belongings are seized and destroyed, compounding trauma and making it harder to find safety or acquire housing. Governments favor temporary housing programs, which often become a revolving door, pushing people back into homelessness instead of offering stability. Peggy Lee Kennedy of the Venice Justice Committee reports that of 109 individuals served through Venice’s Inside Safe program in January 2023, 53 returned to the streets. Launched in 2022 by Mayor Karen Bass, Inside Safe was supposed to temporarily relocate people from encampments to hotels until permanent housing was available. However, the program had limited success, with many returning to the streets due to restrictive, jail-like hotel conditions, inadequate follow-up, and barriers to permanent housing.
Criminalization punishes unhoused individuals and traps them in cycles of fines, warrants, and ultimately jail. Criminal records create further barriers to housing and employment, and formerly incarcerated folks are ten times more likely to become unhoused.
This system ensures that people remain caught in cycles of poverty and incarceration. Meanwhile, the prison-industrial complex profits $74 billion annually from the essentially free labor prisoners provide to big business.
As wildfires ravage LA this winter, it is a cruel irony that prisoners now comprise much of the labor fighting to protect communities, earning just $5 to $10 a day. A glaring contradiction emerges between the efforts to shelter fire victims and the decades-long lack of political will to treat houselessness as an emergency.
To the root of the problem
Since the Supreme Court decision, cities nationwide have intensified efforts to outlaw homelessness. Camping bans in Denver and encampment sweeps in Phoenix mirror LA’s tactics. Despite this, activists, including the National Homelessness Law Center (NHLC), are advocating for legislation to protect unhoused people from arrest for simply surviving. They also call for increased federal investment in affordable housing and services, alongside systemic reforms addressing poverty and lack of housing.
What’s needed are bold solutions to tackle this crisis at its root. Groups like End Homelessness Now–LA (EHN), initiated by the Freedom Socialist Party in 2018, advocate expropriating vacant city- and county-owned properties to create high-quality, permanent, supportive public housing. Public ownership would significantly reduce costs compared to tax breaks, subsidies, and inflated development costs paid to private developers and corporate landlords. EHN also calls for publicly-owned social housing with rents set according to income, ensuring that housing is treated as a basic human right, not a commodity.
These demands are crucial because they aim to shift the housing system from one that enriches developers and landlords to one that guarantees stability for working-class Angelenos. By advocating for public housing and expropriating vacant properties, EHN challenges housing commodification and replaces criminalization with real solutions. These demands offer a blueprint for cities nationwide to address the housing crisis — prioritizing human survival and dignity over profits and ensuring a future where no one is left without a home.
Increase in city-wide bans, 2006–2019
Resting in public places: 78%
Camping in public: 92%
Living in vehicles: 213%
Source: National Homelessness Law Center report on 187 U.S. cities







