Mean streets

Misery grows for unhoused youth and seniors as the social safety net is shredded and poverty is criminalized.

Unhoused woman in San Francisco. There are approximately 16 million available homes across the U.S., yet millions do not have stable housing. PHOTO: Franco Folini
Este artículo en Español

Children, young people, elders and even babies are out in the cold this winter as their numbers skyrocket among those without homes.

 In 2024, the results of the yearly count in January showed the highest population of unhoused folks since records have been kept. And the last two years have brought sharp increases among youth, especially those of color and who are LGBTQ+, as well as among senior citizens and young families.

 No place to call home

 The National Council of State Legislatures estimates there are 4.2 million unhoused children and youth in the US, including about one million who are school age. Some 700,000 are unaccompanied by an adult. The experience leaves scars: those without a home as youngsters are 50% more likely to remain unhoused as adults.

 The causes of the problem are varied. Aging out of the foster care system at age 18 often leads to being unhoused as young people are discharged with no support to fall back on. They often have an unresolved history of trauma, both sexual and emotional. Kids may also find themselves kicked out of their birth family for being LGBTQ+, trans or pregnant. Sadly, the National Network for Youth estimates that one in five unhoused teens will be victims of sex or labor trafficking.

 The high cost of living and the inability to keep pace on a fixed income lead many older adults to become unhoused. Death of a partner, a change in health status, or medical debt and bankruptcy can drive elders out of their homes. Veterans may be impacted by PTSD. The consequences are deadly: unhoused individuals face a 60% greater risk of dying.

 Systemic causes of homelessness

Estimates of unhoused people vary wildly, but all show a dramatic increase. The 2024 annual count of 771,480, while clearly inadequate, is the highest yet recorded. The National Law Center on Homelessness & Poverty estimated in 2018 that each year at least 2.5 to 3.5 million Americans were sleeping in shelters, transitional housing, and public places.

Currently, there are roughly 16 million empty homes in the U.S. This includes houses and apartments. Obviously, there are more than enough places for the homeless to live.

Underlying the reason that folks are unhoused is the affordability crisis. Housing is exorbitantly expensive. The social safety net has been shredded. Benefits like SNAP (food stamps), Medicaid and Social Security have been cut. Unrealistic work requirements and onerous paperwork keep many folks from accessing help. Treatment for mental illness and substance abuse is limited.

In addition, President Trump’s Executive Order “Ending Crime and Disorder on America’s Streets” forces states to choose between using proven methods to address homelessness, such as “housing first,” or losing federal funds.

Kicking the vulnerable to the curb

As the billionaires grow richer, those without resources fall further behind. Unfortunately, as their numbers balloon, efforts mount to criminalize the unhoused.

In June, 2024, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of Grants Pass, Oregon, allowing it to outlaw camping and sleeping on sidewalks or other public areas, even if no other shelter is available. Folks can be fined or jailed for infractions. Some 100 cities have followed suit.

In California, Governor Newsom signed a bill that threatens localities with a loss of funding if they don’t criminalize the unhoused.

Another grave concern is the right-wing demand for forced treatment for mental illness and substance abuse. This punitive approach has been proven ineffective. Punishing someone, destroying their meager belongings, or sending them to an inadequate or unsafe shelter or involuntary “cure” is clearly not a workable plan.

Repairing the safety net and beyond

Right now, there are badly needed reforms that, while definitely not a full solution, could help ease the suffering.

Lawmakers should restore the federal benefits that have been stripped away since the time of Reagan. Empty buildings could be transformed into housing. Efforts to criminalize homelessness should be banned. Public funds and programs to aid people with substance abuse and mental illness should be massively expanded; they need compassion, not punishment.

The special challenges faced by young people and elders on the street must be addressed before they become critical. The foster care system should be reformed so that youth are not abused or dumped out with no resources. Medicare for All would go far in preventing crushing medical debt.

Taxing the rich to reduce the tax burden on working people would also help elders keep their homes.

Does all this sound impossible? Only piecemeal change will happen under capitalism. But a system based on meeting the needs of human beings, not profit, could more than provide for the needs of the most vulnerable in society. Imagine a world where workers democratically make decisions about what to produce and for whom. A world where average citizens, not billionaires, decide their fate.

This scenario is possible under socialism. It is the answer to a rapidly deteriorating dystopia incapable of providing people a roof over their heads. It is an idea whose time has come.