“What we have is the Minister of Defence saying in the immediate post Tampa environment, don’t humanise the refugees.” This is a quote from the October 2002 Senate report on the “Children Overboard” affair. The Howard Government has deliberately tried to suppress individual stories of refugees — who are to be kept nameless and faceless. Freeing Ali, through its moving personal portraits, sets out to do the complete opposite.
In April 2005, Michael Gordon interviewed more than half of the asylum seekers who remained in detention on the island of Nauru as part of Australia’s infamous Pacific Solution. Under this policy, people seeking asylum are held in offshore detention centres. There they are denied the same rights as asylum seekers who get to the Australian mainland by refusing them access to the Australian legal system. Gordon’s stories, which generated an outpouring of public support for refugees, were published in The Age and the Sydney Morning Herald. The book describes the impact of these stories: “Some of those who responded appeared to have been touched for the first time by the consequence of John Howard’s border protection policy. Bruce Armstrong of Rozelle was one such person: ‘as I finished reading about the lost souls on Nauru, the tears were rolling down my cheeks. No newspaper article has affected me like this before.’”
Freeing Ali is a slim volume in the UNSW Press Briefings series of “topical books exploring social, political and cultural issues in contemporary Australia.” The writing style is simple, while the structure is very clever. Gordon tells three inseparably connected stories. The first is the story of Ali Mullaie and the other refugees incarcerated on Nauru. The second is the story of the refugee advocates in Australia working so hard to free them. The third story is the shifting Australian political context.
In 2001 the Howard Government was re-elected after a shameful scare campaign where refugees were vilified. Australian military personnel were ordered to storm a merchant vessel, the MV Tampa, to prevent it discharging in Australia a group of asylum seekers it had rescued at the request of the Australian government. Besides the Tampa Affair, there were also false allegations that refugees had thrown children into the sea. This was followed by the sinking of a boat where 353 people drowned. This was the vessel designated SIEV X by the government. On the eve of the election, two women asylum seekers drowned when their boat sank off Ashmore reef.
Ali’s story. Ali Mullaie was on the Ashmore boat. A young Afghan man, who now lives in Melbourne on a Temporary Protection Visa (TPV), Ali fled Afghanistan at age 18. Gordon recounts Ali’s terrifying story as he attempted to get from Indonesia to Australia on board the unseaworthy coastal vessel. Unable to swim, he spent two hours in the water clinging to a plank of wood after a fire had sunk the boat. Others were not so lucky. Fatema Shahi Husseini, a young pregnant woman making the trip with her husband, who had befriended Ali, was one of the women who drowned.
Ali was taken to Christmas Island and arrived in Nauru in December 2001. He was to spend three and a half years in detention on this impoverished barren island. Gordon paints a portrait of a remarkable young man with incredible leadership qualities. Ali worked as a volunteer teacher and has a glowing reference from the second most senior minister in the Nauru Government, whose son had been taught by Ali.
In June 2005, Ali’s claim for refugee status was finally accepted and he flew into Melbourne to begin a new — if still hard — life in Australia. Ali was elated, but also saddened to leave friends behind on Nauru whose circumstances were similar but whose claims have still not been accepted.
Massive movement. At many rallies for refugee rights, Indigenous activists have spoken out, welcoming refugees to their country, regardless of what the occupiers might say. The day Ali flew into Australia, Arnhem Land artist, Wukun Wanambi, in Melbourne for an exhibition of his bark paintings, gave Ali and his friends a welcome to country on behalf of the continent’s first people.
Ali was also greeted by refugee rights activists who had campaigned against the Pacific Solution and mandatory detention and who corresponded with him during his long Nauruan nightmare.
The stories of many of these activists, most of them women, are woven throughout the text. One is Halinka Rubin, a Polish Jew who fled European anti-Semitism. Halinka is a former workmate and teacher union comrade of mine who, since she retired, has dedicated herself to teaching English to refugees and campaigning for their rights. These vignettes provide a snapshot of the strong and passionate refugee movement in Australia.
Gordon is clear that shifts in public opinion do not just happen by accident. But what is strangely absent from the narrative is any acknowledgement of the mass public protests demanding an end to mandatory detention and the Pacific Solution.
Goron profiles Petro Georgiou, Liberal MP for Kooyong, who wrote the introduction to Freeing Ali. Earlier this year Georgiou pushed the Howard Government into accepting a slight softening of the mandatory detention policy by releasing families from detention centres. In contrast to Gordon, Georgiou does give credit to the massive shift in public opinion and the level of activism among his constituents. He points out that the policy softening does not apply to those in offshore detention centres and makes it clear that he would like to see further changes. Gordon ends the book on a note of optimism when he talks of “a new era, and a new chapter in the story of Ali Mullaie and the others, this one offering more uncertainty but at last the prospect of a happier ending.”
Not yet a happy ending. But while Ali, and others like him, are no longer locked up in a Pacific island jail, they are still far from free. Ali has been granted some protection, but it is not permanent. He will have to reapply again after three years, and he cannot be reunited with his parents and siblings. The refugee rights movement needs to reinvigorate the campaign to get rid of TPVs and provide full citizenship rights for all. At least a resident with permanent residency can claim full social security. A refugee on a TPV has only limited access to a meagre “Special Benefit.” A permanent visa confers nominally free access to education, and those with these visas are eligible for the family reunion program. People living on a TPV must pay full fees for education and have no reunion rights, including with their spouse or children. There is also a range of other problems with accessing essential services, which result in many people living in Australia with temporary protection having to rely on charity to survive.
The softening of mandatory detention negotiated by Petro Georgiou and the other “rebel Liberals” is to be welcomed, but it is crucial to draw the right conclusions from their actions. These politicians felt compelled to act because of the power of a mass movement. It is now time to turn up the heat.
Freeing Ali does a brilliant job of exposing the horror of mandatory detention and the Pacific Solution. By showing the human face of Ali and his friends, Gordon exposes the Howard Government’s harsh demonising approach. He and similarly fair-minded journalists have helped to shift the climate of public opinion from where it was in 2001. But we must not forget the refugees living with daily uncertainty in the community on unfair TPVs. Permanent residency — and all the rights that go with it — is necessary to really free Ali. Gordon would do the movement a great service by using his journalistic skills to show the human face of daily struggle in Australia with uncertain temporary protection.







