Australian Labor Party: No friend of the planet!

On 8 October, less than two weeks after approving three new coal mines, Environment Minister Tanya Plibersek hosted a so-called Nature Positive Summit at the International Convention Centre in Sydney. A lively protest called out the Albanese government’s blatant hypocrisy. Photo by Move Beyond Coal.

As we speed towards climate catastrophe, the Australian Labor Party has shown it is no friend to the planet, or the people and ecosystems depending on it.

The increased global CO2 emissions reported in March was the largest ever recorded, and the rate itself is increasing. As global temperatures escalate, the atmosphere is speeding towards the edge of major climate tipping points — which, when crossed, will cause irreversible cascading damage. The intensity and frequency of extreme weather and natural disasters is rising exponentially. Every week a different catastrophe occurs, taking human life and decimating communities and ecosystems. In October alone, we saw hurricanes leaving trails of destruction across the U.S. and floods ravaging parts of Nepal and Spain.

In Australia, our urban and natural environments are in serious danger. Bushfires, rising sea levels and temperature, as well as deforestation and mining, are killing habitats and endangering the species that call them home. Here and around the world, the people most impacted by the effects of climate change are women, impoverished communities, First Nations people, people of colour and migrants. These groups, already marginalised by compounding systems of oppression, are most at risk of dying as a direct result of environmental pollution or impoverishment as their livelihoods — and lands — are destroyed. Increasing numbers of environmental refugees are displaced from homelands becoming unsuitable for human life. The climate crisis isn’t slowing down anytime soon. It is more and more obvious that climate change poses an immediate existential danger to humans and the ecosystems we live in. As the crisis unfurls around us, pressure is mounting on governments to take action to mitigate the effects.

After months of devastating bushfires, this mass rally in Melbourne on 18 January 2020 demanded urgent action on climate change. Photo by Alison Thorne.

The “Climate Election.” In the wake of the devastating bushfires of summer 2019/20 and an explosion of mass global environmental protest, the 2022 Australian federal election was considered a crucial moment in the fight against climate change. Labor’s position on climate bolstered its electoral platform, and it was considered the strongest viable alternative to the criminal environmental policies of the Coalition. It pledged to reduce national emissions by 43% by 2030, slash the emissions of key industries and to accelerate the rollout of renewable energy.

A year into its term, the ALP announced its “Nature Positive Plan.” In a statement released by Minister for Environment Tanya Plibersek, the government said the initiative would “help us protect more of what’s precious, repair more of what’s damaged, and manage nature better for the future.” At the core of the plan was investing $121 million into building Environment Protection Australia (EPA). The EPA would be an “independent and transparent” watchdog that would be “a tough cop on the beat.” The Nature Positive Plan promised to fix decades of environmental pillaging by the reactionary Liberal-National Party Coalition, which has led to increased loss of natural habitats and endangerment of species. The ALP positioned itself as a champion of nature on the world stage and hosted an environmental conservation summit this October in Sydney.

From the get-go its environmental platform was riddled with contradictions and warning signs of the backsliding to come. Its electoral promises already lagged behind what science showed was needed at the time. The ALP seemed to be in no rush to achieve net zero by 2035, which scientists say is imperative to preventing catastrophic and irreversible consequences. Their proposed policies were kept deliberately vague, even before they were elected, to safeguard against pushback from fossil fuel giants — a not-so-subtle foreshadowing of the policies to come under their leadership.

In the years following the Climate Election, Labor’s grand ideas and dazzling slogans turned out to be nothing more than empty promises and cheap posturing. In total contradiction to its purported climate goals, the federal government continues to approve the expansion of the fossil fuel industry, with over a hundred new fossil fuel projects in the pipeline. A total of seven new coal mines have been approved since 2022.

Carbon intensive offshore gas field development and fracking have enjoyed considerable support under Labor. The Future Gas Strategy has entrenched indefinite gas extraction into the Australian economy. According to experts, even achieving this watered down and conservative goal of a 43% reduction of emissions has proved impossible for the ALP government. This is while it proudly claims that it is well on track. The Victorian Environmental Protection Agency, an already weak state regulator, was further weakened in September this year as the Victorian Labor regime struck a compromise deal with the opposition to get its legislation through state parliament.

Far from “nature positive,” its leadership has shown that the ALP is positively negative in its approach to climate. The legislation embedded within its Nature Positive Plan did not include a timeframe or baseline in which the environment would be restored. This would apparently be decided by the federal EPA, an agency that has proved to possess neither teeth to bite nor legs to stand on. To add insult to injury, the so-called Nature Positive Summit in Sydney was held while logging resumed in Bulga State Forest, less than 400km away. The forest is a critical habitat for the Australian sugar glider, a small gliding possum species.

ALP a willing accomplice in ecocide. Labor has shown it cannot be trusted with protecting the environment from further damage, let alone restoring it from the decades of destruction it has already endured. Its failure to deliver on its promises of environmental reform echo its inability to solve the quagmire of issues plaguing our modern world. Yet the ALP’s criminal inaction on climate change is not a matter of mere incompetence. Labor has shown time and time again that it is the willing accomplice of a capitalist class hell-bent on securing profits at the expense of the planet and the people living in it. The party’s electoral platform relies on historical posturing around its supposed leftwing origins and positioning itself as the only alternative to the greater evil of the Coalition.

With the Coalition proposing its diversionary nuclear policy, (see Reject Dutton’s Nuclear Fraud, page 3) there is an alleged choice between a party moving towards outright denialism or a party that dresses its environmental crimes in glitzy slogans and false promises. In fact it is two roads to the same destination. It’s no surprise that Australians are disoriented in how best to channel their fear and frustration about government inaction in the face of the climate catastrophe. The Greens party, which since the 2022 federal election has enjoyed the largest electoral success in its history, has consistently watered down its policies by compromising with Labor in the name of so-called progress. But that is what happens when you don’t oppose the underlying cause of the crisis — capitalism itself. The Greens has no solution, either.

Labor’s Nature Positive initiative couldn’t make its pro-capitalist positions any clearer, because the driving force behind implementing climate friendly policy is to attract investment from “green” capitalists. Plibersek herself made plain these aspirations about turning Australia into a “green Wall Street.” History has shown how misguided and contradictory this approach is. Mining boss Gina Rinehart — Australia’s richest person — continues to threaten moving industry offshore if government red tape gets in the way of profit. Despite its plan posing no real threat to business as usual for the fossil fuel industry, the ALP has already crumbled under pressure, withdrawing the Nature Positive bill from Senate consideration following criticism from the business lobby.

No climate justice under capitalism. Big capital is inherently opposed to environmental sustainability, a process that requires putting the planet and humanity above the ruthless pursuit of profit. In a global economy ruled by the ever-expanding capitalist market, the drive to accumulate will always supersede human and ecological need. Similarly, as long as we live in this system driven by the profit motive, bourgeois liberal democracy will always prioritise the interests of corporations over its citizens. In a world mired in crisis, the only thing Labor, the Coalition and the Greens can offer is reform so slow that the planet will already be up in flames by the time it arrives. What use is piecemeal reform on a planet that’s already burning?

Climate justice can’t be achieved in a system where policies must be diluted to their most conservative elements in order to pass through a parliament so beholden primarily to the interests of big business. The climate movement has shown this, and the increasingly dictatorial use of legal sanctions gives it emphasis.

Channeling mass social discontent into electoral politics is where grassroots movements go to die. The movement has dwindled to a shell of what is used to be. What, then, is the solution? When governments have shown that they are unwilling to act, and when their environmental regulations are as restrictive as red tissue paper, the people must take power back into their own hands.

Only when we do away with a system dictated by the profit motive, when the economy is run by the people for the people — will we see real action on climate change. This would be a system where progress isn’t held back by the hoarding of wealth by a privileged few or the mindless cycle of overproduction and consumption. It’s a system where production and the abundance it creates are put to rational use in a planned economy based on the needs of people and the planet. This is ecosocialism. And it is only through ecosocialism that we can not only protect the environment from future damage but mend centuries of destruction that capitalist industrialisation has wreaked upon it.

Organise and fight. The climate action movement needs urgent resuscitation. We need to reignite our anger and disrupt the system through protest and striking. The Builders Labourers Federation did exactly this in the 1970s. They proved just how powerful workers can be, by enacting what were called Green Bans and walking off the job when developments were harmful to local ecosystems.

Rising Tide, a blockade happening at the end of November in Newcastle New South Wales, plans to disrupt the world’s largest coal port. Australia is the third largest exporter of fossil fuels in the world. This blockade will hit the industry where it hurts. Join the Freedom Socialist Party and Radical Women contingent travelling up to Newcastle and show the ALP that it can’t keep getting away with its weak action on climate change and that big capital cannot get away with its environmental crimes.