The last couple of months have been a shocker for those fighting for First Nations justice. July ended with the release of the data report which monitors progress toward reaching Closing the Gap targets. It showed that only five of the 19 targets were on track, while four were going backwards. The number of First Nations children placed in out-of-home care, committing suicide or locked up is getting worse! Meanwhile the number of First Nations adults in prison also increased over the last year.
Hot on the heels of the release of this data was a spectacular backflip by Prime Minister Albanese at the Garma Festival. He dumped his commitment to establish and resource a Makarrata Commission. He seemed to think it was enough to repeat endlessly his vague commitment to Makarrata, describing it as a Yolgnu word meaning the coming together after a struggle, facing the fact of wrongs and living together in peace. Meanwhile former commitments to a formal process of Truth Telling and a clear path toward treaties with sovereign First Nations disappeared, like writing in the sand.
If all 19 of the Closing the Gap targets are to improve, it will be essential to first listen to First Nations people and then act. In Victoria, First Nations organisations put five years of effort into working with the state government to hammer out reforms to Youth Justice legislation. After a scare campaign by the cops and the Herald Sun, in mid-August the Allan government betrayed First Nations communities by reneging on a firm commitment to raise the age of criminal responsibility to 14 in 2027. The Victorian Aboriginal Legal Service (VALS) describes this move, gutting a crucial reform at the very last minute without event consulting, as “treachery” and “shameful.”
It is disgraceful that of the almost 600 kids aged 10 to 13 years, who are jailed in this country every year, 65% are First Nations children. For these children, the impact of invasion, dispossession and loss of culture is not history — it is lived experience as they struggle with the legacy of generations of state-perpetrated trauma. Once incarcerated, children are re-traumatised and put on a pathway to adult prisons.
It is more than 33 years since the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody (RCIADIC) made its excellent suite of recommendations, one being that imprisonment must be the sanction of last resort. Instead of making progress on implementing these recommendations, governments — state and federal — engage in simplistic, opportunistic tough-on-crime measures and to hell with the consequences, especially for First Nations people.
Children need safe places and a pathway out of the justice system. To achieve this, governments must invest in community-controlled initiatives that support Indigenous youth and build First Nations resilience. Initiatives such as Balit Ngulu, a holistic legal service for Aboriginal children run by VALS, need more funding. In every jurisdiction, the age of criminal responsibility must be raised to at least 14 and all 339 recommendations of the RCIADIC implemented in full. We also need Truth Telling, leading to Treaties with real teeth, to stop police and rightwing media from continuing to set the agenda.








