Socialist Feminist Recommendations for Nov. 4th New York Election

Dear friend,

As a political party with decades in the trenches, we in the Freedom Socialist Party take elections seriously as an opportunity for the working class to make our voices heard. With Election Day approaching, we’ve put together a guide of our socialist feminist recommendations for what’s on your ballot.

All eyes are on the mayor’s race, where Zohran Mamdani has lit a spark of hope with talk of universal childcare, rent freezes, taxing the rich, and standing strong with Palestine.

His support for these issues sharply contrasts with the other two leading candidates, both of whom have run cynical, fear-based and red-baiting campaigns. Serial sex abuser Andrew Cuomo is clearly ready to work with both big business and Trump at the expense of us all. And perennial right-wing candidate Curtis Sliwa offers no solutions other than more policing and jails.

Mamdani’s growing support reflects how eager many New Yorkers are for a real break from the status quo. The important reforms he’s calling for are just a starting point for what working people need—but the question remains: how can these be won?

As inspiring as the idea of a socialist mayor may be, the FSP believes that lasting change cannot and will not come from representatives in the Democratic Party machine. The Democratic Party is built to protect landlords, Wall Street, the police, and to block any reform that challenges their interests. As one of many examples, the FSP together with other community activists were blocked by City Council Democrats obstructing police accountability measures. Mamdani’s recent meetings with business leaders and establishment figures—along with his softening stance on NYPD reform—already raise alarms that he’ll compromise on key issues to get along at the cost of the working class.

Both the Democrats and Republicans have contributed to the drastic inequality and conditions we face today because above all, they serve capitalism. For that reason, we cannot endorse Mamdani or any other candidate running on the Democratic ticket.

The groundswell of support for Mamdani highlights the potential for not only new candidates, but also for a new party. We are among the chorus of growing calls to form a Labor Party as an independent vehicle to represent working people without billionaire manipulation. A Labor Party that can cultivate the brave leaders we need to fight back against this rotten system. Working and poor people deserve no less, and the conditions are overripe for unions and the Left to get together and build one.

Regardless of who occupies Gracie Mansion, meaningful progress will depend on strong, independent movements that can organize and apply pressure from below. FSP is committed to being part of that struggle every step of the way.

One additional note on candidates: you may have run into a group called the Socialist Workers Party at recent protests and marches. While they call themselves socialists, their platform has been moving more rightward, with support for Trump and Israel among other reactionary positions. We urge you to steer clear.

Ballot Proposals
There are a number of items on the New York ballot. Here are our recommendations:

Proposal #1: Amendment to Allow Olympic Sports Complex To Use Protected Forest Land – Vote NO

New York’s Adirondack Park is protected as “Forever Wild,” with any changes requiring statewide voter approval. This measure would retroactively legalize illegal encroachments the Mount Van Hoevenberg Olympic Sports Complex made on protected land, in exchange for the state adding 2,500 new acres to the park sometime in the future.

It’s outrageous that the Olympic Regional Development Authority (ORDA), a state agency, violated the constitution by developing on protected land. This amendment lets ORDA dodge accountability in return for a modest land addition already funded by taxpayers.

Some environmental groups support it as a way to expand protected land, but New York already has millions set aside for that in the Environmental Protection Fund. Voters shouldn’t be asked to bless ORDA’s unconstitutional actions. We need stronger community oversight of development and preservation. Vote NO.

Ballot questions #2-6 are from Mayor Adams’ Charter Revision Commission. As context, once a charter revision commission is empaneled, only their proposals can be placed on that year’s ballot. Increasingly, this is being used to strengthen the mayor’s political chokehold by preventing the City Council from putting measures on the ballot, and would also block any citizens’ initiatives. This is Adams’ go-to-tactic to further consolidate power in the executive branch, echoing what’s happening on the state and federal levels.

This year’s Charter Revision Commission focused on the city’s critical housing shortage.

Proposals #2, 3 and 4 on Affordable Housing – Vote NO

These three measures are designed to sound great on the surface. They would ostensibly speed up approval of “affordable” and “modest” housing by taking away the City Council’s responsibility to review and give final approval to projects. Instead, decisions would be made by the City Planning Commission, the chairperson and majority of members of which are appointed by the mayor.

Bypassing the role of the City Council, whose members are accountable to the neighborhoods that elected them, removes one tiny bit of control voters currently have over the corrupt and exploitative real estate industry, a loss which will inevitably impact poor, people of color and immigrant neighborhoods the hardest. For this reason, we oppose the changes in #2, 3 and 4.

However, keeping the City Council’s role in place is no panacea for the city’s desperate need for quality housing people can actually pay for. Predatory developers are banking billions with ever diminishing regulation. They wield a heavy hand in “fast-tracking” housing projects, which often results in scrapping accessibility accommodations and undercutting safety and quality.

For the future, we need truly effective measures on the ballot. These would greatly increase funding for quality, accessible public housing. Decisions on location, construction and occupancy should be made by the communities they serve, not mayoral appointees and the corrupt corporations they cater to. Housing must be seen and treated as a human right.

Proposal #5: Create a Digital City Map to Modernize City Operations – Vote YES

Currently, the official maps of the city are on paper and spread out among the five borough offices. If this question is passed, the Department of City Planning would combine and digitize the maps, making them more readily available. We don’t see a down side to bringing the city map into 21 st century technology.

Proposal #6: Move Local Elections to Presidential Election Years to Increase Voter Participation – Vote YES

Currently, city officials are elected in odd-numbered years. The given rationale for synching them with presidential and congressional elections is to increase turnout. A second point in favor is that history indicates a more decisive shift in policies and representation is facilitated by having all elected positions come up for new votes at the same time. A YES vote adds one small bit of voter-power in a system with little true democracy.

* * *

No matter the results this November, the Freedom Socialist Party will be in the streets, in our unions, and in our communities fighting for the world we deserve. With the blitz of vicious and cruel attacks by the Trump regime, from ICE raids to threats of siccing the National Guard on civilians, the most important thing the working class and our organizations can do right now is come together in united fronts to repel these assaults on our communities. In this effort, the strength of organized labor is needed more than ever. Ultimately, only replacing capitalism with socialism will provide the lasting relief the working class and poor need.

Please reach out if you would like to join or volunteer to help our efforts. Freedom Hall, our organizing center in Harlem, is open Monday and Wednesday from 12-6pm, so please stop by to visit our bookstore and say hello!

As always we welcome your feedback on this letter. Don’t hesitate to reach out.

In solidarity,

Jed Holtz
Organizer,
NYC Freedom Socialist Party