Single-issue survey denies unionists a real voice

Share with your friends


Shortly after the federal election, I received an electronic survey from my union, the

Australian Services Union. The leadership was asking for members’ feedback on the

election and the Your Rights at Work campaign. I thought: this is great — members get

to say what we think.

Since the union movement’s focus on the Your Rights at Work campaign shifted from

fighting to voting, I definitely had things to say! Especially after my union did not

endorse an all-union rally in September to protest Howard’s anti-union laws, but instead

put all of our resources into electing a Labor Rudd government which had pledged to

muzzle militant unionists.

So I got straight into the survey. After preliminary questions about my union

membership, I hit the first snag: which of these parties did you give your voting

preferences to and which are you closest to — Liberal, National, Labor, Democrats,

Green, the ultra-right One Nation or Other. I was not the only unionist who voted for

socialist candidates, but there was no box for us. I ticked “Other/Independent” and


The next hitch was identifying the issues that influenced my vote. Political leadership,

healthcare, education, industrial relations laws, climate change, housing affordability

were all good offerings. But “security and the war on terrorism” (what about our

civil liberties!), “management of the economy” (the profit system needs an overhaul,

not management!), and “Australian jobs and protection of local industries” (reeks of

nationalism) bothered me. Absent were: the war in the Middle East, even though Rudd is

sending more troops into Afghanistan; women’s reproductive rights, even though parts

of the union movement are running campaigns for paid maternity leave and childcare,

and abortion rights is again a hot issue; rights for lesbian/gay/bi/transgender/intersex

workers, even though many unions have active queer caucuses, and same-sex relationship

rights is a national campaign; Aboriginal rights, even though unionists — Indigenous and

non-Indigenous — are involved in the resurgent Aboriginal rights movement. Worst of

all, we had to choose one as “the single most important issue” that decided our vote in the

election! This stumped me. I couldn’t answer the question.

I wondered about the purpose of the survey. I’m hardly alone in thinking of anti-capitalist

alternatives and acting on these many battlefronts. Union members talk about these issues

every day. We march in the streets, and we organise.

The survey highlighted the gulf in our unions between the officials and the members

they claim to represent. It froze out the voice of radicalism, which is growing in the

membership as the multi-issued struggles of our lives intensify. This is what scares top

union officials as they try more desperately to preserve a fragile status quo: they’re scared

of rank-and-file radicals and militants rocking the boat!

Share with your friends